Appetizers
Fried Jalapeno Poppers
Stuffed with cheddar and served with sauce
King Kong Fries
Steak, chicken, green peppers, fried onions, cheese sauce, mozzarella and provolone baked and served with ranch
Garlic Toast with Cheese
Bacon Cheese French Fries
Hearty portion of fries with melted provolone, mozzarella and cheddar topped with bacon and a side of ranch
Stuffed Hot Peppers
Homemade stuffed banana peppers baked with marinara sauce. Add cheese $1.00
Soft Pretzels 2 For
Soft Pretzels 3 For
Salads
Plain, Cajun, or BBQ Grilled Chicken
Lettuce, tomato, red onion, green peppers, hot peppers, black olives, chicken, french fries, cheese
Marinated Steak
Grilled sirloin steak marinated in our house italian dressing, lettuce, tomato, red onion, green peppers, blade olives, fries, cheese
Antipasta
Lettuce, tomato, red onion, green peppers, hot peppers, black olives, salami, capicola, cheese, hardboiled egg, anchovies
Smokehouse Chicken Salad
BBQ Chicken breast, crumbled baron, topped with onion rings and cheddar cheese over fresh bed of lettuce
Pasta
Traditional Pasta Marinara
Any one of our imported pastas, tossed in our homemade sauce
Chicken & Sausage Mafalda
Chicken breast and hot sausage served over penne pasta with a red cream saute
Linguini Clam
Old world recipe with red or white sauce
Penne Arrabiate
Spicy blend of hot banana peppers, olive oil & garlic in our marinara sauce
Chicken & Garlic
Tender strips of chicken breast sauteed with olive oil, garlic and our own blend of spices, served over penne pasta
Five Layer Lasagna
Hearty portion of pasta bye red with meaty marinara sauce and a blend of four cheeses baked until bubbly
Rigatoni Casserole
Rigatoni and hearty meat sauce topped with mozzarella and provolone cheese then baked until golden brown
Hot Sausage Casserole or Meatball Casserole
Served over a bed of pasta topped with mozzarella and provolone cheese then baked to perfection
Family Style Pasta Casserole with Meat Sauce
Served with bread, butter and salad. Serves 3-4 people
Sandwiches
Hot Turkey, Roast Beef or Meatloaf
Served on italian bread, smothered in homemade gravy
Chargrilled or Fried Chicken
Served with lettuce and tomato
Cajun Grilled Chicken
Cajun grilled chicken breast with lettuce and tomato
Smokehouse Chicken
Grilled BBQ chicken breast topped with bacon, cheddar cheese and onion rings
The Good Fello
Sliced capicola and provolone piled high with fried egg, coleslaw and french fries on thick sliced italian bread
Burgers on the Grill
Swiss, Bacon, Mushroom Burger
Lettuce, tomato, bacon, mushroom, swiss cheese
The Gibby Burger
Grilled capicola, marinara sauce and provolone cheese
Baked Hoagies
Beef and Cheddar
Roast beef, cheddar cheese sauce and golden fried onion rings
The Nero
Our classic italian with extra salami, ham pepperoni, mozzarella and provolone
Kids Menu
Cheese Burager
Served with fries
Sicilian Thick Square Pizza
Chicago Style Pizza
Pan baked with cheese and seasoned crushed tomatoes. 14" 10 cut Pizza: 1/2 topping $0.90, one topping $1.80
Original Calzone
Fresh pizza dough stuffed with pepperoni, sausage, provolone, mozzarella and ricotta, cheese served with marinara sauce
Custom Calzone
Fresh pizza dough stuffed with your choice of two pizza toppings, provolone, mozzarella and ricotta, cheese served with marinara sauce
Stuffed Hot Pepper Rolls
Stuffed hot banana, mozzarella and provolone cheese rolled into pizza dough
Sides
Vegetable of the Day
Al a Carte Jambalaya
Desserts
Homemade Pie by the Slice
Specialty Dessert
Make your pie a la mode. Add scoop of ice cream for $1.25
Beverages
12oz. Can
Goodfello’s Pizza Pasta & Grille, located at 124 N Main St in Zelienople, serves a generous mix of Italian favorites and American comfort food. The menu covers traditional and specialty pizzas, pasta dishes, calzones, baked hoagies, burgers, sandwiches, salads, wings, appetizers, desserts, and soft drinks. Popular recommendations include the Chicago-style square pizza, White Pizza, BBQ Chicken Pizza, Original Calzone, and hearty Godfather sandwich.
Prices are approachable for casual dining, with substantial portions offering solid value for individuals, families, and groups. Fresh pizza dough, flavorful sauces, melted cheeses, crisp vegetables, and well-seasoned meats create satisfying combinations of richness, freshness, and texture. Vegetarian diners can choose cheese or vegetable pizzas, salads, meat-free pasta, and customized calzones. Gluten-sensitive guests should confirm available substitutions and preparation practices directly with the restaurant. The children’s menu and familiar choices such as pizza, burgers, pasta, and fries make ordering easy for younger diners.
Goodfello’s is best suited to relaxed lunches, dinners, family meals, takeout nights, and group gatherings rather than traditional breakfast. Shareable pizzas, appetizers, hoagies, and desserts also make it a convenient choice for parties and casual celebrations.
Menu Highlights
Chicago-Style Pizza
This thick square pizza is pan-baked with melted cheese and seasoned crushed tomatoes. Its crisp edges, soft center, and comforting flavor make it a filling house favorite.
White Pizza
A creamy, cheese-forward pizza delivers a rich taste without traditional tomato sauce. Its soft, savory topping and chewy crust make it especially popular with cheese lovers.
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Tender chicken, smoky barbecue sauce, and melted cheese create a sweet and savory combination. It stands out as a flavorful alternative to classic pizza varieties.
Original Calzone
Fresh dough is filled with pepperoni, sausage, ricotta, mozzarella, and provolone before being baked until golden. Marinara served alongside adds bright acidity to the rich filling.
Stuffed Hot Pepper Rolls
Hot banana peppers and melted cheeses are wrapped in pizza dough and baked. Their gentle heat and gooey center make them a distinctive appetizer or shareable snack.
The Godfather Sandwich
This substantial sandwich combines sliced capicola, provolone, fried egg, coleslaw, and French fries on thick Italian bread. Its bold flavors and oversized construction make it one of the menu’s most memorable choices.
Spinach Feta Pizza
Fresh spinach and tangy feta provide a lighter, savory topping combination. The contrast between creamy cheese and tender greens makes it a strong vegetarian-friendly selection.